Engineering Board Exam Reviewer · ECE · hard

On May 1, A mailed B an offer to sell testing equipment. B mailed his acceptance on May 5. On May 6, before receiving B's letter, A sent a revocation that reached B on May 8; B's acceptance reached A on May 10. Was a contract perfected?

  1. Yes, on May 5 when B mailed his acceptance
  2. No; under the cognition theory a contract is perfected only when the offeror learns of the acceptance, and A revoked before that
  3. Yes, on May 10 regardless of the revocation
  4. Yes, because offers by mail cannot be revoked

Answer

B. No; under the cognition theory a contract is perfected only when the offeror learns of the acceptance, and A revoked before that

Solution

Article 1319: acceptance by letter binds the offerer only from the time it came to his knowledge.

More ECE questions

  1. Under Article 1723, if a building collapses within 15 years due to defects in construction, and the engineer who supervised the…
  2. A ₱2,000,000 contract has two approved change orders: an addition of 8% and a deduction of 3% of the original contract price. What is the…
  3. A ₱500,000 balance for a completed radio installation remained unpaid for 2 years after judicial demand. Using the 6% per annum legal…
  4. The Philippine Competition Act, which created the Philippine Competition Commission, is:
  5. A 'kickback' in procurement refers to:
  6. When an engineer believes a client's project will not be successful or economical, ethical practice requires the engineer to:
  7. A dispute resolution process in which a neutral third party helps the parties reach a voluntary settlement, without imposing a decision, is:
  8. The Alternative Dispute Resolution Act of the Philippines is:
  9. The principle that no one shall be unjustly enriched or benefited at the expense of another is found in:
  10. Article 19 of the Civil Code (the 'abuse of rights' principle) requires every person, in the exercise of his rights and performance of his…

All ECE questions