Civil Service Exam Reviewer · Reading Comprehension · hard

Preparing for the Big One

Scientists cannot predict the day an earthquake will strike, but they can estimate what a large one would do. Studies of the West Valley Fault, which runs through parts of Metro Manila and nearby provinces, have modeled a strong earthquake that could collapse many buildings, start fires, and cut roads and water lines, a scenario popularly called "the Big One." Such studies are sometimes criticized for spreading fear, since no one knows whether the event will come in ten years or two hundred. Yet their purpose is not prediction but preparation. By identifying which areas and building types are most at risk, they allow governments to prioritize the retrofitting of schools and hospitals, plan evacuation routes, and stockpile supplies where damage would be greatest. For households, the lesson is similar. A family cannot prevent an earthquake, but it can secure heavy furniture, agree on a meeting place, and keep water and a first-aid kit ready. The uncertainty of timing, which seems to make preparation pointless, is in fact the strongest argument for it: because the event could come at any time, the only sensible moment to prepare is now.

How does the author respond to the criticism that such studies spread fear?

  1. By claiming the studies predict earthquakes accurately
  2. By arguing that fear helps sell emergency supplies
  3. By agreeing that the criticism is correct
  4. By pointing out that the studies are meant for preparation, not prediction

Answer

D. By pointing out that the studies are meant for preparation, not prediction

Solution

Right after the criticism, the author says: "Yet their purpose is not prediction but preparation."

More Reading Comprehension questions

  1. According to the passage, the purpose of earthquake scenario studies is to
  2. Which example would the author most likely cite as open data working well?
  3. Calling open data "a tool rather than a solution" implies that
  4. The passage mentions all of the following limitations of open data EXCEPT that
  5. The sentence "Experience has tempered this optimism" means that
  6. Which statement best expresses the main point of the passage?
  7. The author's attitude toward surgical checklists is best described as
  8. What is the "less obvious benefit" of the checklist?
  9. The advocates' argument that a checklist is "a support for" skill means that
  10. Why did some professionals resist checklists at first?

All Reading Comprehension Reviewer questions